Most of the industry sells owners on how bookings arrive:
New AI technology.
20+ channel partners carrying the listing.
~30% in direct bookings.
But that only says how the booking got there.
And it says absolutely nothing about what their homes actually earn.
Here are the only four things that matter when evaluating a new vacation rental property manager or revenue partner:
1. Your real keep on bookings
Start with everything the guest paid.
Then list who takes what: the taxes, the platform, the manager's base commission, the manager's guest facing fees, cleaning, etc.. all of it.
Any fee the manager charges the guest and keeps is commission, whatever they call it.
Take a five-night, $10K booking (before tax). The manager adds a 10% “guest fee” and a $150 in-house damage waiver on top, so the guest pays $11,150.
The manager keeps the 30% commission ($3,000), the guest fee ($1,000) and the waiver ($150).
That’s $4,150, not the $3,000 you’d expect. It’s over 37% of what the guest paid, not 30%. And that’s before incidentals and housekeeping.
We work in luxury, and you'd be surprised what managers get away with. We’ve seen gratuities charged at booking that never reach the staff, and even tax lines set above the actual tax rate.
Ask for one real booking and audit the breakdown from the top line down.
Then put your share next to EVERYONE else's full take on the true gross.
2. What the home earns against the median for its competitive segment.
Most firms advertise the same kind of number: a 20 to 30% increase, benchmarked against the market average or a home's previous underperformance.
Both are very low bars, and neither is your competitive segment.
A market average includes its smallest and lowest-earning properties. What a one-bedroom condo earns at under $100 a night says nothing about a four-bedroom home at $1,000 to $2,000 a night.
The larger the firm, the closer its results sit to the median. Firms at the median still sell a lift on every home that arrived below it. That measures the last manager, not this one.
A home's competitive segment is every home that can take its bookings, and nothing else.
Whoever runs your home’s revenue should be able to list all the vacation rentals in your competitive segment, and show exactly where each home they already run ranks in its own.
In premium and luxury segments, $150k, even $250K can sit at the median for a home's competitive segment.
Winning bookings from homes above your segment is how a home outperforms it.
Hotels have measured this for decades. It’s called the Revenue Generation Index (RGI).
An RGI takes what a hotel earns per available room, divides it by what its competitors earn, and multiplies by 100. At 100, the hotel is earning its fair share. Above 100, it is taking revenue from its competitors.
The same number works for a home: its annual revenue, divided by the median for its competitive segment, times 100. A home at 100 earns the median. A home at 250 earns two and a half times the median.
Ask any manager for that number on the homes they run.
Under a full mandate, ours typically sit near 250 and have reached as high as 585 (almost 6 times the median), often outperforming homes worth significantly more—homes they shouldn't be able to compete with on paper.
3. What the home costs to operate.
Platform fees (~15% of every booking)
Maintenance
Housekeeping,
Landscaping,
Pool, hot tub, sauna
Property systems (plumbing, electrical, HVAC)
Pest control
Testocking
Utilities
Property damage protection plans
Admin (legal & accounting)
Ownership costs come on top: insurance, property tax, debt service (if any).
Platform fees are often the largest operating expense and the most overlooked. They come out before the money arrives, so there is no bill and rarely a line on a report. They scale with revenue: $15K on $100K in bookings, $30K on $200K.
For housekeeping, count the turns: at 70% occupancy and five-night stays, that is about 50 a year. At $500 a turn, that is $25K before anything else.
Add it up for the full year. That total is the baseline.
If you keep less than that in a year, you are paying out of pocket to rent the home.
Then question the lines.
In-house housekeeping should cost less than an outside team, because an outside team's rate already includes its margin. A vacation rental manager taking 30%+ of bookings should not also earn a margin on turnovers.
If the manager uses outside vendors, audit the invoices for markups.
In any other real estate investment, you would expect the manager to net you well above the cost of running the asset.
4. How many homes in the firm's portfolio turn a profit for their owners?
Twenty years of experience can be twenty years of homes that lost money while the manager got paid.
Most vacation rental managers don't publish what their homes earn because the numbers would work against them.
On the rare occasion one does, it is usually a top-line number from one of its best homes.
Nothing about that is misleading in any way.
But the top line is not what the owner keeps.
Take out transient tax, about 15% to the platforms and 35% or more to the manager, and less than half is left.
Against that, a luxury home costs six figures a year to operate.
We’ve audited homes running $150K gross whose owners were losing $30K to $50K a year before insurance and property tax, and without a mortgage.
We took on a home at $150K. It made over $500,000 in our first year and runs over $700,000 now.
For a luxury home under a traditional vacation rental manager, the break-even on operations is about $250K in bookings, transient tax included.
Again, that’s before ownership costs of insurance, property tax and debt service.
Ask how many of the firm’s homes clear break-even, and by how much.
Everything else is downstream of those four numbers.
The best housekeeping team or review profile doesn't matter if the home doesn’t exceed its carrying costs.
If your vacation home is losing money under your manager, ask them for these numbers today. The answers may shock you.
The truth is most vacation rental property managers are housekeeping operations at their core.
In luxury, some come from real service backgrounds. Former butlers and house managers, strong on service and attention to detail.
They handle guest questions and complaints during stays. After that they clean, they turn the home over. And when something breaks or is missing they report it and call a vendor.
The work matters—a lot. The quality has to be there.
But being a great house manager does not make the home a profitable asset.
Those two are worlds apart.
A five-star stay does not produce a $500,000+ year, any more than a great plate of pasta makes a profitable restaurant.
Quality supports the revenue. It doesn't create it.
Demand architecture does.
But it’s easy to fake.
An app. Dynamic pricing tools. A guest database. Ten recognizable booking platforms. Hundreds of millions of travelers a month. Direct bookings.
It all looks impressive, even sophisticated.
None of it is an advantage, because everyone has it. Every competing home is on the same platforms, in front of the same travelers, priced by tools that pull the same market data.
Same inputs, same result: the median.
The largest managers call themselves hospitality companies. They are closer to technology companies, and the more homes they run, the closer their results sit to the median.
A listing on Airbnb is like a website on Google: it's there, and so is everyone else's.
Direct bookings are the easiest of all to misread.
Often the guest found the home on a platform, then booked direct because the manager had priced the platform higher. It’s calledthe billboard effect.
The fee that was saved went to the guest as a discount, not to the owner. And the listing lost a booking that would have helped it outrank its competitors.
That’s the platform's demand, booked somewhere else.
It is distribution and syndication. Not demand architecture.
The four numbers are the part that can't be faked.
Here is how we structure a mandate around those four numbers: Our Approach →
Start a conversation
to explore fit.
Jack Laurier is a disciplined asset management firm for luxury Single Family Leisure (SFL) real estate. We source, underwrite, and steward rare vacation homes in irreplaceable markets as trophy hospitality assets for investors and family offices.
Explore fit